Enviroshake vs. Other Roofing Materials
Other Synthetics
Comparison Material
Assorted composites
8
Commonly 30–50 year warranties, often prorated over time
Light; standard framing
Class 3 or 4, varies by manufacturer
Varies by manufacturer & fastening system
Ranges Class A–C by product & assembly
Generally low; cracked units need replacement
Polymer / rubber blends, composition varies
30–50 years; transferability varies
You're comfortable comparing individual synthetic products closely on their own merits
Metal Roofing
Comparison Material
Steel / aluminum / copper
7
40–70+ years
Light; standard framing
Can dent under hail even while functional
Varies widely by panel system
Non-combustible; assembly-dependent rating
Low, but coatings and fasteners need occasional attention
Steel, aluminum, zinc, or copper
Separate material, coating and workmanship terms
A contemporary metal aesthetic fits your architecture, and longevity is a top priority
Clay Tile
Comparison Material
Fired clay
6
Long service life when maintained
Approximately 600 lbs per square
Brittle; cracks from hail, debris, foot traffic
Some systems tested to approximately 110 mph
Non-combustible; Class A achievable
Low, but cracked tiles need individual replacement
Fired natural clay
Varies by manufacturer; often not transferable
You want the look of traditional clay tile and your home can bear the weight
Natural Slate
Comparison Material
Quarried stone
4
75–100+ years
800–1,500 lbs per square
Brittle — cracks underfoot & from hail
Excellent when properly installed
Non-combustible
Low, but repairs need slate specialists
Quarried natural stone
No manufacturer warranty; installer dependent
Maximum longevity matters more than weight, cost or ease of repair
Asphalt Shingles
Comparison Material
Standard shingle
5
10–25 years
Light; standard framing
Granules dislodge, can fracture under hail
Varies by product; can lift or tear
Often Class A; some Class B/C
Low early on, more frequent as it ages
Petroleum-based asphalt mat
Varies by manufacturer & product line
Keeping upfront roofing budget as low as possible is the priority
Cedar Shake
Comparison Material
Natural wood
3
20–30 years with upkeep
Moderate; standard framing
Can split from hail or debris
Depends on install quality & age
Class C standard; Class A with treatment
High — preservatives, cleaning, periodic replacement
Renewable, harvested from old-growth stands
No manufacturer warranty on the wood itself
Authentic natural aesethics are the top priority despite high upkeep
Enviroslate
Enviroshake Product
Composite slate
2
50+ years
Approximately 275 lbs per square
Class 4 (UL 2218)
180 mph, third-party tested
Class A assembly available
Very low — resists freeze-thaw damage
95% post-industrial recycled content
Fully transferable warranty
You want a heritage slate look at a fraction of the weight and cost
Enviroshake
Enviroshake Product
Composite cedar shake
1
50+ years
Lightweight — no reinforcement needed
Class 4 (UL 2218)
180 mph, third-party tested
Class A assembly available
Very low — no preservatives or refinishing
95% post-industrial recycled content
Fully transferable lifetime warranty
You want authentic cedar character without the maintenance of real wood
Request a Sample
Experience the authentic look, texture, and quality of Enviroshake up close when you get your free samples. Explore our colors and choose the perfect fit for your home with confidence.
